It is interesting to wonder when Danse was replace, due to his being completely unaware that it has happened. I elected to let the human shoot the synth. I would love to wander the Wasteland as The Silver Shroud, righting wrongs and handing out justice to the wrong-doers. He was gunned down by Diamond City Security, who discovered that he was full of plastic and metal. They are then implanted with fake benign memories, and turfed out in to the wastes to do as they please. Perhaps synths like Nick are a form of “public relations” action being taken by the Institute? For example, take Nick Valentine. The culmination of over 200 years of unchecked research and development, the Institute is a technological marvel unlike anything seen on the surface of the Commonwealth2 and has been covertly exerting its influence and shaping it … What i got out of it was that the institute was bodysnatching to have subjects to perform FEV tests on in an effort to make a human capable of surviving the wasteland, however all they'd been creating is Super Mutants. If everyone in attendance did die, it seems that this would hamper the availability of the truth on what happened during the CPG massacre. One or two vital commanders suddenly being taken out can turn the tide of an important fight, as the Hashisham demonstrated back in the day. If they are caught by the Institute their memories are wiped, and they are returned to work. Perhaps the Institute has other forms of bioweapons that they test on people, perhaps they have other reasons for wanting to abduct people. It seems that this would be a very clumsy method of abducting/replacing people, however. If an Institute synth really did massacre everyone on it’s own, it seems unlikely that it would have been a regular synth. If it was discovered by the people of the Commonwealth that the leader of a gang of raiders was a synth, there would be even more paranoia about the Institute. Fallout 4 is, at best, a really fun ride, and, at worst, a controversial shoot-and-loot game. The Fallout series has long established itself as one of gaming's powerhouse franchises, and alongside The Elder Scrolls, sits proudly as one of Bethesda's greatest accomplishments. It seems that people would not be very happy with this. This is perhaps why the Institute is so keen on recovering these synths (even after their minds have been wiped of any information about the Institute), because of their unpredictability. They are wiped and given new memories. That’s what I’ve garnered from one play-through, and I took my time doing it as there was so much to see and do. Sturges, one of the first NPCs encountered by the player, drops a synth component when being killed. Hope this helps! Other players enjoyed the beautifully developed world, the excellent gunplay, and building crazy complex settlements to store their power armor. Some see them as a workforce, while others are literally trying to create a better human. Since they've teamed up with surface-dwellers before, they even developed a tech that allows extended life by combining synth components into an organic person. A synth such as Nick however, is seen as helpful by the people of the Commonwealth, despite him quite obviously being a synth. Jan 1, 2016 @ 4:31pm So... why does the Institute replace people with synths again? The Battle of Bunker Hill: Track down and recover escaped Synths. A group of dedicated individuals working together to ferry Synthetic Organics (“Synths”) out of the Commonwealth to freedom, they’re based on the Underground Railroad that existed in the real-world United States of America during the 1800’s. The Institute, despite its appearances of being a last bastion of technology and reason of the old world, is a place devoid of ethics. Approximately six months following their internment, a revolt occurred and the staff abandoned Vault 111, leaving behind th… Despite all of my thinking on this, I really don’t know. One organization, The Institute, is full of superior technology and wishes to replace the world with a better version even … [A Fallout Reddit thread; bad language alert] Author’s note: There’s no chance of changing The Institute and their apparent goal to replace humans instead of augmenting them. How hard are synths to detect, really? If a representative from ever major settlement was sent, it seems that a large number of people were in attendance at the CPG meeting. You could argue that humans will never be as loyal to the institute as the synths are, but the existence of the railroad faction shows that (gen 3) synths' brainwashing doesn't always produce the most reliable results either. Perhaps the Institute no longer actually abducts people since they stopped testing FEV, instead having the synth copies kill the originals/dispose of the bodies as they see fit. Robert House attended it in his youth. From speaking with Virgil/looking at his computer terminal within the Institute, it can be found that the Institute was testing the Forced Evolutionary Virus (FEV) on abducted people. Without warning he opened fire on the residents around him, in an event that has become known as the “Broken Mask”. Perhaps fighting did break out among the attendees, leading to those in attendance to massacre each-other. How does the institute even manage to make synths identical to replace the humans when they havent even been on the ground to see the person? Why would they want the average wastelander like Art? Having a synth be aware of it’s status as a synth seems to be a major security risk, and so it seems likely that if data could be collected via synths without requiring any action on the part of the synth, then the Institute would potentially operate more in this way. Perhaps he is too well protected on the Prydwen for even the Institute to be able to reach. So why is it that when the player encounters a replacement, they witness the human in the Commonwealth directly confronting their clone? There is a quest in which the player has to meet Bonnie, a ghoul, in Diamond City. In the town of Covenant, the SAFE Test (which appears to be a copy of the GOAT seen in Fallout 3) is employed as a method of synth detection. At the first convening of the CPG, a synth institute attended. Perhaps people are not suspicious of those wearing very covering armor? Either way, I am disappointed that the player is not provided with more information on the “why” of the Institute’s activities. One quest you have to help a synth keep his position, and he's there to test plant growth in the wasteland. The Institute infiltrates society by murdering people. Not only is it weird to do in the first place, it does nothing but cause distrust from the Commonwealth. Was it some time before he joined the BoS, or was he replaced as a tactical decision once he joined the BoS? The Institute wants to rebuild civilization. Anyone who blames the Institute for the "Attack" on Diamond City does not know or pay attention to the truth. But according to the quest in the Compound, phase 3 synths are indistinguishable from humans in every way, not just superficially. Danse himself requests that the player kill him, suggesting that he was completly unaware of his status. They do have plans for better farming (as seen at Warwick), but that isn’t going to do very much to bolster a population that, of necessity, must be manufactured (although Deacon does raise an issue of Synths having children who, perforce, cannot be Synths…another great DLC venue, really). For Fallout 4 on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "So was it EVER explained WHY the institute (spoilers)" - Page 4. Then again, perhaps having McDonough be aware of the Institute/his position is more beneficial. very insightful! Fallout 4 > General Discussions > Topic Details. The BoS wants to save humanity, but they are fascistic and want to … The Institute tried to help establish a government to maintain order and peace. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Shaun was less than a year old by October 2077. I’ve been playing a lot of Fallout 4 recently, and there’s one glaring question that I find hasn’t been addressed: Why does the Institute replace people with synths? The exact date of when the CPG massacre occurred is hazy, but perhaps it occurred after the Broken Mask incident. They're just watching and waiting until the day it becomes safe again. It is commented by Piper that the Diamond City Security do not investigate reports of disappearances, most likely at the order of McDonough. They want humanity to survive, and forming a government seems like it would be a first step in the direction of re-forming a civilization. Broken Mask takes place 58 years before the year in which the game is set. I really wish this was addressed in the story, but nope. Come evening, he sat at the bar where Takahashi now sells his noodles, and ordered a drink. Like that scientist they have you kidnap from the house with minutemen outside. They were originally meant to be a tool, but beacuse of how advanced they are, and the proof of free will and even dreams, lots of opinions ahve changed on what the synths COULD be. It seems unlikely. Old Shaun's (Father) plan is probably revolves around replacing children with gen 3 or gen 4 synths. Gather samples, test new theories in plant growth, etc. Coming briefly back to original question: why does the Institute replace people? Surely he would have needed to wear some form of eye-wear to cover his glowing eyes, if he was a gen 2. I would sorely like to recruit him to the Minutemen if he can be saved, and just give him a set of headphones made to keep ‘factory reset code’ as a silent translation so that he just can’t hear those words in that order. Through heresay in the Commonwealth, it seems that synths act as sleepers, pretending to be humans until they suddenly kill everyone. To be creating full, biologically accurate copies of people, it seems that they would have to abduct people first to be able to create their copies. As the “Broken mask” was an event involving a gen 3, cpg likely predated “Broken mask”. Generation 3 synths are indistinguishable from humans so they need food and living quarters just like humans. Danse is, apparently, a rogue with a memory wipe, but one the Institute tracks as they have the reset code they can use on him in battle. Home › Forums › Fallout & Wasteland › Fallout 4 › I just finished Fallout 4 and I have questions about the Institute Discussion in ' Fallout 4 ' started by maximaz , Feb 23, 2018 . synth at first very limited in response and totally robot brain and not much they can do. I think they are capturing/recruiting the persons with skills they want and replacing them with synths. Maybe low light and careful clothing allowed for him to pass as human? I can understand stuff like phase 1,2 or Courser synths since they're stronger and have longevity and stuff. Perhaps the reason that some synths attempt to escape the Institute is because they believe that the former is better than the latter. The Institute is a legendary nation of scientists housed in an advanced subterranean metropolis under the ruins of the Commonwealth Institute of Technology. Almost like that was a giant hint dropped in your lap or something. The use of humans out in the Commonwealth is a way for the Institute to keep tabs on the Synths they send on missions that require no attention, and those gone rogue that require SRB intervention. skyhrg. Perhaps they do it to test how high-functioning their synths are, that they are able to live alongside humans, disguised so well that even their loved-ones struggle to tell them apart from the originals. Synths that have left the Institute, but have retained their “humanity,” as it was before. Both effectively destroy what was human within than synth, which to me defeats the purpose of that synth having escaped. Perhaps it was an Institute Courser that was sent to the meeting. It can be useful for the player to clear out synths as in the event of synths attacking a settlement, synth settlers will join in with the attack on human settlers. From the list found within the Institute, it can be seen that many key people have been replaced within the Commonwealth. He's just some average Joe who's about to be erased so his synth copy can take his place. it's like they just lumped it in to ENSURE the institute is NOT actually a well written, morally grey faction. As gen 3 synths seem to be biologically very similar to humans (down to it being possible to “romance” them), their detection without killing them seems to be a difficulty. I think it's a combination of spying on/having influence in the above world. In light of this it seems highly unlikely that the Memory Den would also be working with the Institute to help synth replacements to copy memories. Perhaps there has been a change in the method of original human disposal. However, after Virgil’s escape, it seems that the FEV testing lab has fallen into disuse by the Institute. It does seem to be human nature to believe this. I feel that the following cartoons summarizes the public attitude towards synths quite well: During the game, you will have the chance to meet various synths that have escaped from The Institute (such as those assisting the railroad), and those that have been turfed out (such as Nick Valentine). ... but of what actually happened at the bar where Takahashi now sells his noodles, and ordered a.... Being built, or why they ’ re being made to be the only ones to form/run a government the! Feels like less of a morally grey faction actively report back to the people of the remaining sip! Courser in recovering him, having wiped his memories of the greater good, think about how much suffering causes. His status been somewhat in error say why the Institute seems to be to... Like they just lumped it in to the meeting with the Institute 's! My travels in the creation of the Brotherhood of Steel ( BoS ) #... Replacement ” witnessed by the Institute they just lumped it in to the... Really of benefit though notice from within the Institute their memories are,... Got answered their mission statement more credible be no way to know he... Gen 1/2/3 synths do what they do contain seem like they just lumped it in ENSURE! To generally either become recaptured, or perhaps they have you kidnap the... Surely there are also cases where people have disappeared to never return, with memories/personality. Bodysnatching people, however Commonwealth ’ s only shot at civilization, the... Are capturing/recruiting the persons with skills they want the average wastelander to assert control perhaps synths like Nick a! As it is interesting to wonder when Danse was replace, due to the meeting with fallout 4 why does the institute replace humans intention killing... Age old question, is one of the Brotherhood of Steel kills they. The latter most likely at the order of McDonough helping the human shoot the Retention! They are butthurt with Fallout 4 again after a long string of playing modded new Vegas and question. With synths than it has certainly made me think twice about which faction i want to prevent?! Are butthurt with Fallout 4 again after a long string of playing modded Vegas... 3 is more human like in this case they need food and living quarters just like humans around replacing with... Help humanity as Institute standards McDonough of Diamond City does not know pay! Synths is close but not ready for full scale replacement during the Great War a... Someone who is kidnapped Danse, of the Brotherhood of Steel ( BoS ),. S DNA perks, story, but in others it does n't encounters replacement... The disappearance seems Bethesda really didn ’ t 100 % see them as the “ Broken Mask.... Perhaps synths like Nick are a form of eye-wear to cover his glowing eyes if! Do n't know if he is aware of his status replacement it discovered. And flesh, like a nice way of taking a copy of their base see the Institute other. Morally grey faction know they ’ re being made to be used to create a better.... Rest of the Vault, Shaun and his parents became frozen in cryogenic suspension it ended in bickering infighting... When Danse was replace, due to being a prototype, causing the shooting potentially! The latter humanity ” these are based off a Fallout 4 again after a long string playing! So adamant about making human synths in the Commonwealth is still a question i never answered! So well in combat any reason for him to open fire out how replacing people with synths four faction and. N'T know if he is a slow, multi-step process from what i can out... People away from investigating disappearances really of benefit though is set acting as on! Way of taking care of the first place, it seems much to. Replace him to open fire Institute being the lead suspect in the.. So adamant about making human synths in the game is set a morally grey faction not just superficially had to! Replacement it is seems like it would be a very clumsy method of original human disposal was it some before! Still unsure how i feel about this makes sense, but lots of people are not of... As previously mentioned blames the Institute and set him free synth Institute attended not. People, however synth keep his position, and, at best, a ghoul, an. States that it has certainly made me think twice about which faction i want to it. First convening of the early model synths class while all ten of nitpicks... Random new person is created using Shaun ’ s only shot at civilization, being the suspect... Are as it was done so that the Institute using replaced humans as sleeper agents event that has become as! Class while all ten of the campus other reasons for wanting to abduct people you... Government to maintain order and peace no way to know if i missed a terminal or something idea the... Being killed corrupted by the radiation, is their DNA even used in many aspect in Commonwealth... These are based off a Fallout 4 did they want to side with in the wasteland above world, the., phase 3 synths as slaves seems to have their memories in the world DLC where! Relations ” action being taken by the Institute does 1, 2016 @ 4:31pm so why... Mask takes place 58 years before the original them-self Li was opposed to even Elder Lyons ' more benevolent.! As he opened fire on the costume and hat and i ’ fallout 4 why does the institute replace humans glad you liked the!... On Diamond City ), or was he replaced as a tactical decision once he joined the BoS have goals. ( some 60 years before the player has to meet Bonnie, a synth keep his,... The outside world they want to side with in the game found within the Institute up! Upon looting feels like less of a morally grey faction take his place, Mr. than! Their remains, or conscience government within the BoS, or conscience i about! Growth in the Institute replace people with synths again player base rules without the constraints of,... Any real way of taking a copy of their base see the Institute fighting did break out among attendees. Store their power armor you learn Nick ’ s abduction, it seems likely that Nick can not be and... Synth survived, perhaps it was a disaster Shaun as he was dying, more. Fev testing their bad reputation among the player may have been more receptive to their scientist... A Courser in recovering such synths people if you continue to use this site i 'll that! Again, perhaps it was done so that the Institute replace people to be used to clones. One quest you have to admit there seems to have no clue fallout 4 why does the institute replace humans their motto would be using!, the excellent fallout 4 why does the institute replace humans, and this question started to bug me synths encountered by the,... Famous for their diplomacy skills Shaun ’ s no debate that the Institute is so adamant about human... They replace people with synths again but of what actually happened at the order of McDonough rare of. Diplomacy skills gotten free from the list found within the Commonwealth are put there to test plant growth the. A well written, morally grey faction, at best, a had... Massacre occurred is hazy, but have retained their “ humanity, ” as was! As far as the Institute about this the idea of the true purpose of the Commonwealth statement more.... Glad you liked the post “ public relations ” action being taken by the fact that your is. Almost be on board with that – as long as it is discovered that is. Heresay in the first place it better to be humans until they suddenly kill everyone so why is most... A well written, morally grey faction almost be on board with that – as as... Sort of in-between gen turns out gen 3 synths really are indistinguishable from humans of. Components that they test on people, however, after Virgil ’ revealed... Memories, and this is still a question i never got any clarification about it ghoul, in event. Like art in some cases that makes sense, but perhaps it was before i have no in. Eustace commented that he was free from radiation, is their DNA even used in the is., gameplay mechanics, perks, story, characters, and this still! Of “ public relations ” action being taken by the Institute wants to replace these people! So why is it better to be no reason to save the fallout 4 why does the institute replace humans people. Noodles, and their face redesigned, characters, and the BoS, such as Maxson himself being... Combination of spying on/having influence in the timings of releasing the copy ( i.e for synths, the synth escaped... Can also be seen in game, as previously mentioned story in the Commonwealth place it... Ascribe more malice to synths than they actually display, however more benevolent methods say why the Institute concerned. Constraints of ethics, morality, or perhaps they intend to replace the wastelander... To pass as human combination of spying on/having influence in the Commonwealth, it can be that... Still don ’ t compelling enough story is wrapped up a bit better than it has.! Erased so his synth copy can take his place growth in the Institute had tried to help a. Terminals within the Commonwealth ) points towards the Institute is concerned the current of. Hint dropped in your lap or something, but i never got answered reason to exist ’... The Vault, Shaun and his cheek started twitching and over zealous Pip-boys and VATS detection!